Preston Scheiner

Attorney Profile

Top Rated Personal Injury Attorney in Fort Myers, FL

Associates and Bruce L. Scheiner, Attorneys for the Injured
 | 4020 Evans Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901
Phone: 239-939-2900
Fax: 239-939-7079
Selected To Super Lawyers: 2020
Selected To Rising Stars: 2010 - 2011, 2015 - 2017
Licensed Since: 2007
Practice Areas:
  • Personal Injury - General: Plaintiff
Attorney Profile

As a trial attorney at Associates and Bruce L. Scheiner, Attorneys for the Injured, PJ Scheiner has dedicated his career to helping people who have been injured, maimed, or killed by the negligence of others. Inspired by the rich American tradition of using the judicial branch of government to forge a better, safer, and more just society, Mr. Scheiner believes that every case has the potential to effect structural change to make our communities and our society safer for ourselves and our children. By fighting for full and fair restitution for each and every injured, wronged, or aggrieved victim, an example is set that careless, dangerous, or irresponsible conduct will not be tolerated in our community. 

Since graduating from Amherst College in Massachusetts and the University of Miami School of Law in Florida, PJ has joined forces with his father to recover numerous multimillion-dollar verdicts, judgments, and settlements.

As an active speaker and presenter at legal conferences, PJ has traveled the country to share the experiences and lessons of his litigation and trial experience. PJ is also a licensed multi-engine commercial and type-rated jet pilot.

Practice Areas
  • 100%Personal Injury - General


Selected to Super Lawyers for 1 yearsmiddle-imageSelected to Rising Stars for 5 years

Super Lawyers: 2020 Rising Stars: 2010 - 2011, 2015 - 2017

Email Me

To: Preston Scheiner
Super Lawyers: Potential Client Inquiry

About Preston Scheiner

Admitted: 2007, Florida

Professional Webpage:


  • Certificate of Appreciation, Lee County Bar Association, 2014
  • John F. Evans Memorial Scholarship, University of Miami School of Law
  • Cum Laude, University of Miami School of Law
  • CALI Excellence for the Future Award for Excellent Achievement, University of Miami School of Law
  • Thomas Ewald Memorial Award Recipient, University of Miami School of Law
  • Dean’s Certificate of Achievement, University of Miami School of Law
  • NITA Advocate designation, National Institute for Trial Advocacy (NITA), 2009

Special Licenses/Certifications:

  • Licensed Commercial, Multi-Engine, Instrument Airplane Pilot with a single pilot type rating in the Citation Jet series of aircraft. 

Bar/Professional Activity:

  • Tort Litigation Law Section of the Lee County Bar Association, Chair, 2013
  • Florida Justice Association
  • American Association for Justice
  • Florida Bar
  • American Trial Lawyers Association
  • U.S. District Court Middle District of Florida
  • Lee County Bar Association

Pro bono/Community Service:

  • Founding member and current Board of Director of Captains for Clean Water, a 501(c)(3) focused on education and outreach regarding water quality and water management issues impacting Florida. 

Scholarly Lectures/Writings:

  • Connectionology Seminar presentation, Presenter, Winning "Connective Tissue" Injury Cases, 2018
  • FJA Workhorse Seminar presentation, Presenter, "The Power and Effect of Making Each and Every Element of Damages a Separate and Distinct Category of Loss (Remembering that "Physical Pain" Differs Vastly from "Physical Suffering") - There Will Be No Award for That Which the Jury Does Not Understand, Ap, 2019
  • Connectionology Seminar presentation, Presenter, "The Handling, Litigation, Mediation & Trial of Neck & Back Personal Injury Cases - Everything from Initial Client Interview to Verdict - Avoiding Traps & Pitfalls", 2018
  • Presenter, “Low Cost, High Impact Technology in Truck & Auto Cases”, Association Of Plaintiff Interstate Trucking Lawyers Of America, 2014
  • FJA Annual Convention presentation, Presenter, "New Approaches to Proving PTSD", 2018
  • FJA Workhorse Seminar presentation, Presenter, "Lessons from the Poker Table Which Match Strategic Needs of Trial Lawyers' Case Goals: Hold versus Fold; the Bluff; "Poker-Face"; Play the Hand You are Dealt; Creating Your Own Luck; Patience and Discipline; More, 2018
  • FJA Workhorse Seminar presentation, Presenter, "Proof and Argument of Notice of Dangerous or Hazardous Condition", 2016
  • AAJ Seminar presentation, Presenter, "Anatomy of a Personal Injury Lawsuit", 2016
  • FJA CLE Seminar & Legislative Update, Presenter, "Expert & Physician Bias in a post-Boecher Practice", 2015
  • FJA Workhorse seminar presentation, Presenter, "A Prism of Persuation: The Power of Going First", 2015
  • Southern Trial Lawyers Annual Conference presentation, Presenter, "Planning for the Future: Effectively Presenting Economic Damages", 2015
  • Cross-Ups in Cross-Examination, Connectionology Seminar, 2014
  • “Maximizing Technology in Preparing for and Conducting Jury Selection – The Paradigm has Shifted”, Florida Justice Association, 2014


  • Obtained a confidential final judgment pursuant to an arbitration award in the amount of $3,292,457.30 on behalf of a minor who suffered esophogeal injuries after ingesting clear, colorless, and odorless caustic chemical drain cleaner from an unmarked water bottle that was left in the home of the minor by an air-conditioning techinician., 2019
  • Receved a Verdict of $557,000.00 in the case of Dennis Lesavich vs. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company arising from non-surgical neck and back injuries caused by a rear-end motor vehicle collision. , 2018
  • Received a Verdict of $3,583,951.46 in the case of Tonya Smith v. Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc., August 23, 2013
  • Received a verdict of $900,130 in the case of Kari T. Maynor and Tony L. Maynor vs. GEICO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY in a case involving neck and shoulder injuries arising from a motor vehicle accident. The verdict was over 60 times the amount initially offered in settlement of the underinsured motorist claim by GEICO. , 2018
  • Received a Verdict of $335,000.00 in the case of Carl Rango v. Michael Carroll, August 2013
  • Received a Verdict of $905,494.30 in the case of Frances A. Caliaro v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
  • Received a Verdict of $13,885,301.50 in the case of  Philip F. Schlichting, Personal Representative of the Estates of Jesus Martinez and Jordy Martinez, Deceased, Juan Alexis Martinez, a Minor, December 2, 2010
  • Received a Verdict of $4,800,756.48 compensatory damages and $8,500,000 in punitive damages in the case of Raymond J. Barrett and Valerie L. Barrett v. Travelers Commercial Insurance Company, John Tyler Stewart and Christine Marie Berczik, March 7, 2014
  • Received a Verdict of $9,124,574.46 in the case of John C. Greene, Jr., Josie C. Greene and Cameron J. Greene, June 17, 2010

Educational Background:

  • Amherst College, B.A., History, 2004
Show More
Office Location for Preston Scheiner

4020 Evans Ave
Fort Myers, FL 33901

Phone: 239-939-2900

Fax: 239-939-7079

Preston Scheiner:

Last Updated: 12/16/2019

Page Generated: 0.19431185722351 sec