Joseph P. Postel
Top rated Insurance Coverage attorney in Chicago, Illinois
Lindsay, Pickett & Postel, LLC![Joseph P. Postel](https://cdn.superlawyers.com/image/upload/q_auto,f_auto,w_200/v20250124/p/attorney_by_uuid/7e99adb9-4e01-473d-886a-b1da96bba67d/joseph-p--postel-lgr2osli.png)
Practice Areas: Insurance Coverage, Appellate, Civil Rights; view more
Licensed in Illinois since: 1985
Education: Willamette University College of Law
Languages Spoken: English, French
Call today:
312-741-4007
Lindsay, Pickett & Postel, LLC
200 W Madison StSuite 3850
Chicago, IL 60606 Visit website
Details
Joseph P. Postel boasts a distinguished legal career with an exclusive focus on insurance coverage litigation and counseling. In 2006, he became an integral part of the Chicago, Illinois, office of Lindsay, Pickett & Postel, LLC, having previously dedicated 20 years to serving as an in-house defense and coverage litigator with a prominent property and casualty insurer. Presently, He holds the esteemed position of coverage department lead at the firm, extending his legal guidance to clients in both the Chicago Metro area and throughout Illinois.
Mr. Postel’s vast knowledge encompasses various coverage areas, including:
- Commercial General Liability (CGL)
- Commercial and personal auto
- Homeowners
- Farm owners
- Law enforcement liability
- Civil rights liability
- Directors and Offices (D&O) enterprise liability coverage
Of notable mention, Mr. Postel excels in matters involving construction defects and additional insured coverage under CGL policies. While he derives satisfaction from securing victories for his clients, he places equal importance on conflict prevention and achieving amicable settlements. He holds bar admissions in Illinois, granted in 1985, and is authorized to practice in the United States Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit, as well as the U.S. District Courts for the Northern, Central and Southern Districts of Illinois. He is also rated AV-Preeminent* with a 5/5 peer-review score through Martindale-Hubbell.
With over four decades of experience encompassing complex litigation and appeals, Mr. Postel has exclusively focused on coverage for nearly 30 years. He earned his law degree from Willamette University College of Law in 1982, following his graduation from Willamette University College of Arts & Sciences in 1979. Although he pursued his college and law school education in Oregon, Mr. Postel remains deeply rooted in his native Illinois, tracing his lineage back to coal miners and canal diggers in the Illinois Valley.
In addition to his impressive legal career, Mr. Postel is an active member of several professional associations, including the Illinois State Bar Association, the Illinois Defense Counsel and the Defense Research Institute. These memberships reflect his commitment to maintaining a strong professional network and staying updated on the latest developments in his field.
*AV®, AV Preeminent®, Martindale-Hubbell Distinguished and Martindale-Hubbell Notable are certification marks used under license in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell certification procedures, standards and policies. Martindale-Hubbell® is the facilitator of a peer-review rating process. Ratings reflect the anonymous opinions of members of the bar and the judiciary. Martindale-Hubbell® Peer Review Ratings™ fall into two categories – legal ability and general ethical standards.
Practice areas
Insurance Coverage, Appellate, Civil Rights, Construction Litigation: ConsumerFocus areas
Appeals, Construction Defects, Insurance
- 50% Insurance Coverage
- 20% Appellate
- 20% Civil Rights
- 10% Construction Litigation: Consumer
First Admitted: 1982, Oregon
Professional Webpage: https://www.lpplawfirm.com/joseph-postel/
- Illinois, 1985
- U.S. District Court, Southern District of Indiana, 2000
- Illinois Defense Counsel
- Defense Research Institute
- Illinois State Bar Association
- U.S. District Court for the Central District of Illinois
- U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Illinois
- U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois
- United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit
- Judgment on the Pleadings – Successful Post-Settlement Target Tender of Excess Policy: RLI Ins. Co. v. Acuity, no. 20 C 5530, 2022 WL 36100 (N.D. Ill. 2022)
- Summary Judgment – Boyfriend of Insured’s Resident Daughter Not Entitled to Coverage for Accident While Driving Insured Vehicle, Since He Had No Drivers License and therefore could not have Reasonably Believed he was Authorized to Drive Vehicle: Rockford Mutual Ins. Co. v. Thomas, No. 17 MR 161 (Circuit Court of Knox County, 2018)
- Judgment on the Pleadings – Farm Insurer Owes No Duty to Defend Tenant Farmer Against Contribution Claim by Grain Dealer Sued by Farm Landlord for Supplying GMO Herbicide That Killed Crop: Rockford Mutual Ins. Co. v. Weiss, No. 18 MR 329 (Circuit Court of LaSalle County, 2019)
- Judgment on the Pleadings – Village Not Entitled to a Defense for Lawsuit Alleging Police Officer Sexually Exploited a Minor: Illinois Municipal League Risk Management Association v. Village of Lindenhurst, No. 2018 MR 582 (Circuit Court of Sangamon County, 2019)
- Summary Judgment – Additional Insured Must Exhaust Its Self-Insured Retention Before Excess Policy Pays: Acuity v. Commonwealth Edison Co., No. 21 CH 1877 (Circuit Court of Cook County, 2021)
- Judgment on the Pleadings – No Coverage for Architect for Multi-Million Dollar Construction Defect Suit: Cornice & Rose Int'l, LLC v. Acuity, No. 21 C 6112, 2022 WL 4481448 (N.D. Ill. 2022)
- Selected as Illinois Leading Lawyer each year from 2013 - Present
- Rated AV Pre-eminent by Martindale Hubbell
- Willamette University, BA, 1979
- “What Insurance Defense Counsel Need To Know About The Duty To Defend,” IDC Quarterly, March 2006
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Annual Construction Risk Conference, International Risk Management Institute, Washington, D.C., November 1997.
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Insurance Coverage Litigation Committee, Tort and Insurance Practice Section, Annual Mid-Winter CLE Meeting, American Bar Association, Scottsdale AZ, February 1998
- Presenter, “Construction Defect Insurance Coverage,” Construction Defect Seminar, Insurance Coverage Litigation Committee, Tort and Insurance Practice Section, American Bar Association, Marina del Rey CA, June 1998
- Presenter, “Construction Defect Insurance Coverage,” Annual CLE Meeting, American Corporate Counsel Association, Washington, D.C., November 1998
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Tort and Insurance Practice Section, Insurance Coverage Litigation Committee Annual Mid-Winter CLE Meeting, American Bar Association, Monterey CA, February 1999
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Annual Construction Risk Conference, International Risk Management Institute, Chicago IL, November 1999
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Insurance Coverage & Claims Seminar, Defense Research Institute, Chicago IL, May 2002
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Insurance Coverage & Claims Seminar, Defense Research Institute, Chicago IL, May 2003
- Presenter, “Additional Insured Coverage,” Annual Construction Risk Conference, International Risk Management Institute, Chicago IL, November 2003
- Panelist, “Legal Malpractice Claims Against Insurance Defense Counsel/Conflicts of Interest and The Insurer’s Right to Control the Insured’s Defense,” Insurance Coverage & Claims Seminar, Defense Research Institute, Chicago IL, April 15, 2004
- Presenter, “The New ISO Additional Insured Endorsement Forms,” Fall Seminar, Illinois Defense Counsel, Lake Geneva WI, September 10, 2004
- Panel Moderator, “Insurance Defense Counsel’s Ethical Obligations & The Tripartite Relationship,” Construction Insurance Symposium, Illinois Defense Counsel, St. Louis MO, September 20, 2007
- Presenter, “Duty to Defend, Reservation of Rights and Estoppel—The Latest Decisions on The 2004 ISO Additional Insured Endorsements,” Complex Claims Symposium, Illinois Defense Counsel, Oak Brook IL, March 25, 2010
- Presenter, “Risk Shifting and Transactional Planning,” Municipal Attorneys Seminar, Illinois Municipal League, Bloomington IL, April 19, 2013
- Presenter, “Shifting Risk from Municipal Self-Insurance Pools to Commercial Insurers in Situations Involving Multiple Coverage,” Defense Counsel Seminar, Illinois Municipal League Risk Management Association, Springfield IL, August 16, 2013
- “Recent Trends in Additional Insured Coverage,” IDC Quarterly, December 1996
- “Survey of 1997 Additional Insured Cases,” CGL Reporter, International Risk Management Institute, Dallas TX, 1998
- “Survey of 1998 Additional Insured Cases,” CGL Reporter, International Risk Management Institute, Dallas TX, 1999
- “Insurance Coverage for Vicarious Liability,” Construction Risk Manual, International Risk Management Institute, Dallas TX, 2000
- Insurance
These comments were made by fellow attorneys during the annual nomination process.
“Joe has a truly encyclopedic knowledge of coverage law, from concepts to cases to the historical background for the Court's evolution in its opinions. He provides prompt, comprehensive, and correct advice to clients. He also provides excellent mentoring to younger attorneys starting out in the coverage world. His clients appreciate his honest and forthright approach.”
“Joe is a leading authority in the field of coverage law. He is a tireless researcher and writer, intent on keeping up-to-date on all new case law. He provides excellent client service, with timely and accurate reporting and opinions. Clients know that they can trust his advice.”
Selections
- Super Lawyers: 2024 - 2025