Practice areas: Personal Injury; view more
Licensed in Indiana since: 2004
Education: University of Illinois College of Law
Selected to Super Lawyers: 2025 - 2026 Call today:
317-618-8883
Free Consultation Loyalty Law, LLC
600 East Carmel DriveSuite 114
Carmel, IN 46032 Visit website
As founder and owner of Loyalty Law, Jamison J. Allen has built a reputation as a tenacious advocate for injured Hoosiers. For the vast majority of his career, he has been exclusively committed to helping injury victims obtain full compensation for their losses. Jamison has recovered compensation for the full range of injuries: everything from trucking collisions to wrongful death to premises liability and more.
Jamison graduated from the University of Illinois College of Law and was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2002. However, he decided to take the Indiana Bar Exam two years later to return to his boyhood home. Today, he leads a growing team dedicated to using skill and compassion to protect injury victims.
An active member of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association, the Indiana State Bar Association, and the Trial Lawyers College litigation group, Jamison remains committed to mentoring new attorneys, sharing advice to help other attorneys' clients, and ensuring that the promise of justice is accessible to all Hoosiers. Whether negotiating a pretrial settlement or challenging injustice on appeal, his commitment to protecting the rights of the injured does not waver.
True to the name Jamison chose for his law firm, Loyalty Law operates on three guiding principles - courage in the courtroom, integrity in every decision, and an unrelenting pursuit of justice. Jamison made headlines in August 2022 when he secured a $3 million jury verdict for his 93-year-old client in a case where the independent mediator encouraged Jamison and his client to settle for an amount that ended up being only 13% of the jury verdict Jamison obtained. Jamison and his client had the courage to ignore the pressure to settle and instead fought for justice at trial. As lead counsel for the entirety of the case, Jamison not only obtained full compensation for his client but also helped elderly plaintiffs across Indiana obtain higher offers from insurance companies in future cases.
Beyond his success at trial, Jamison's appellate experience places him in an exclusive group of Indiana litigators who have won an Indiana Supreme Court case. Jamison was the principal brief writer in Clark v. Mattar (148 N.E.3d 988, Ind. 2020), a landmark decision that requires judges to remove biased jurors who are reluctant to compensate injured plaintiffs for emotional distress and other non-economic damages. Jamison's drive to win this case was a result of his commitment to give every injured party the right to a fair and impartial jury.
Practice areas
Personal Injury - General: PlaintiffFocus areas
Animal Bites, Motor Vehicle Accidents, Personal Injury - Plaintiff, Premises Liability - Plaintiff, Trucking Accidents, Wrongful Death
- 100% Personal Injury - General: Plaintiff
First Admitted: 2002, Illinois
Professional Webpage: http://loyaltyinjurylaw.com/about
Bar / Professional Activity
- Indianapolis Trial Skills Group member, 2026
- Filed a Petition for Transfer with the Indiana Supreme Court in a case where the Court of Appeals determined the trial judge had no basis to refuse a jury instruction Jamison requested at trial. Jamison requested the instruction to explain the relevant Indiana law and guide the jury on how to handle the fact the defendant destroyed the video of the incident. The case is Ludwig v. Flaherty & Collins, 25A-CT-00941. , 2026
- Jamison started his own law firm on January 1, 2026. After more than 20 years of experience as a partner and trial lawyer in law firms, Jamison realized he needed to start his own law firm to practice law in a manner that puts the injury lawyer stereotype to shame. Jamison did not do what the vast majority of injury lawyers do and name his law firm after himself. Instead, Jamison chose the name "Loyalty" to identify what his firm delivers and to separate his firm from the pack. , 2026
- At the request of the Indiana State Bar Association, in June 2026 at ISBA's annual Solo & Small Firm Conference, Jamison taught trial skills to attorneys from all over the State of Indiana. Jamison's presentation stressed the importance of treating all people as individuals instead of numbers, being humble enough to realize the best ideas often come from people with less education than a trial lawyer, and simply outworking the opponent., 2026
- At the request of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association, in May 2026 at ITLA's annual Lifetime Achievement Seminar, Jamison taught other attorneys the essential steps to take immediately after an injury to preserve evidence and hold wrongdoers responsible if they destroy video or other evidence. Although Jamison drafted and revised the letters multiple times over the years with the wisdom gained as a trial lawyer, Jamison shared the actual letters he uses with other lawyers. Jamison does not want any injured person denied justice, and without any expectation of payment he feels he has a social duty to help other lawyers protect their clients from corporate greed. , 2026
- Sustaining Member of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association, 2026
- Indiana State Bar Association member, 2026
Verdicts / Settlements (Case Results)
- $300,000.00 settlement. The injury was a Lisfranc fracture (bones at the top of the foot) and caused by a disputed fault motor vehicle collision where the plaintiff hit a vehicle that pulled out in front of her. The paid medical bills totaled $52,699.43., 2023
- Obtained a policy limit settlement in a case covered by all major local and state media organizations. The case garnered media interest because the fatal crash occurred at an intersection local residents had identified as exceptionally dangerous, with multiple crashes and complaints to the City of Indianapolis over the course of several years. The crash occurred on September 14, 2025. Jamison's efforts to influence the safety decisions of the City of Indianapolis continues not only in this case, but in two non-fatal cases he signed in 2026 occurring at different but still dangerous Indianapolis intersections. , 2026
- Settled a case for the six-figure policy limits in April 2026, even though he only learned of and signed the case in January 2026, the case was 18 months old at signing, and the offer on the case was $0 on the day Jamison signed the case., 2026
- $475,000.00 settlement. The plaintiffs were an elderly married couple. The settlement included tortfeasor policy limits and underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage policy limits for the wife. The settlement also included tortfeasor policy limits for the husband and was only $25,000.00 short of UIM policy limits. The UIM carrier initially claimed the tortfeasor policy limits overpaid the husband and then only made an offer of $7,000.00 prior to litigation. When the case settled one week prior to trial, the UIM carrier agreed to pay $125,000.00., 2024
- $500,000 settlement. The plaintiff was injured when part of a vehicle driving in front of him broke off and penetrated his windshield. The injuries included a concussion and scar. Paid medical bills totaled $54,961.00. In addition, no one knew the identify of the tortfeasor driver or vehicle when representation started because the driver did not stop and the broken vehicle part was generic and not traceable to any specific vehicle., 2025
- Won an Indiana Supreme Court case as second chair and wrote significant portions of the appellate briefs. Clark v. Mattar, 148 N.E.3d 988 (Ind. 2020)., 2020
- $250,000.00 policy limit settlement. This case involved a disputed fault motor vehicle collision with multiple injured parties and a low-policy limit tortfeasor policy. The plaintiff's injuries involved a femur fracture and surgical repair., 2024
- $250,000.00 settlement. The case was a disputed fault trip and fall on a sidewalk at a Cracker Barrel store. The plaintiff was an elderly woman with a comminuted fracture comminuted fracture of the right distal radius and a right ulnar shaft fracture. The paid medical special damages were $55,923.17., 2024
- $250,000.00 settlement. Paid medical special damages were $23,693.74. The case involved a disputed fault trip and fall injury. The primary injury was a torn left quadriceps., 2023
- $3,000,000.00 verdict for 93-year-old Plaintiff. Kane v. Metropolitan Property & Casualty Insurance Company d/b/a MetLife, 49D01-1812-CT-050373. The case was tried August 9-11, 2022 in Marion County Superior Court 1. The Honorable Heather Welch presided. Plaintiff did not submit the medical bills into evidence. Defendant then also declined to submit the medical bills into evidence. Defendant disputed fault and requested a defense verdict. Injuries included a fractured elbow with surgery and a fractured pelvic bone not requiring surgery. The jury placed 0% fault on the plaintiff and awarded damages in the amount of $3,000,000.00., 2022
- $260,000.00 settlement. The plaintiff was working on a construction site in Tippecanoe County when equipment struck his head while he chose not to wear a hard hat given to him. Injuries included a TBI where he was initially unconscious. The plaintiff was admitted to the hospital and released three days later. He also had a soft tissue injury to the knee. He treated with workers compensation doctors who released him from treatment three months after the injury. The insurance carriers were Accuity Insurance and Cincinnati Insurance Companies. The case is Valencia v. Purdy Materials Inc., Purdy Materials Equipment LLC, Purdy Concrete Inc., Purdy Concrete Equipment LLC. 79D01-2208-CT-000127. Attorney Jamison Allen was lead counsel for plaintiff., 2023
Pro bono / Community Service
- Served pro bono as the special administrator for the estate of the family of an innocent woman who lost her life when she was shot simply because she arrived for work at an incorrect address., 2025
- Served pro bono as counsel for a local arts organization to develop best practices to provide a space that welcomes, protects, and respects everyone. , 2023
Other Outstanding Achievements
- From May 2024 - May 2025, Jamison achieved six figure settlements in eight cases where the insurance company initially denied the claim entirely. Five of these cases settled for a quarter-million dollars or higher.
Honors
- Selected by Super Lawyers as one of the top Hoosier personal injury attorneys., Selected by Super Lawyers, Super Lawyers, 2025
Office location for Jamison J. Allen
600 East Carmel Drive
Suite 114
Carmel, IN 46032
Phone: 317-618-8883
Selections
- Super Lawyers: 2025 - 2026
